In my role as the patient safety innovation coordinator for the Armstrong Institute, I spend a lot of time helping clinicians improve processes in health care delivery. Oftentimes I've found that when faced with a challenge we all have a tendency to go right to solutions we're comfortable with. Especially in health care, we’re used to working within so many constraints that we sometimes miss the opportunity to look at not just what's viable and technically feasible, but also what's desirable for everyone involved.
To help people think beyond the obvious to what we call wild ideas, I use a process called design thinking — a human-centered design approach that was popularized by IDEO. And within these wild ideas, we often find elements that are very useful not only in solving problems, but also in increasing the satisfaction of all the people involved in a process.
So how does it work? Here are five steps to design thinking that I've adapted from the IDEO methodology:
Step 1: Learn. The traditional way of learning in health care is to read all the literature about a topic and talk to a few people. But what we think we know from that research might not be what we need to know. The learning step in design thinking is based on empathy. It involves talking to end users of an entire system to understand their needs. For example, at Johns Hopkins we're working on improving the way emergency code teams are deployed in the hospital. The goal of this project is to ensure that all patients are responded to in an efficient, reliable, effective way. So we're interviewing patients, families, nurses, doctors, pastoral care, security personnel and others to get input from everyone involved in the process.
Step 2: Define. This is where the team comes together to share insights from step 1. For our emergency code team deployment challenge, we stuck Post-it notes on a huge wall identifying themes that included technology, workflow and communication needs. We realized that some larger, long-term system fixes were required. And we identified opportunities for improvement that we could tackle right away.
Step 3: Ideate. In this step, you get people together through focus groups or brainstorming workshops, and come up with ideas for the ideal state of the situation you’re working on — letting ideas flow without any limitations. What could you do if you had no constraints, financial or otherwise?
Step 4: Prototype. After coming up with a bunch of ideas, you pick one or two and create prototypes. A prototype, for example, might be a physical representation of a solution. Sometimes we use cardboard, colored tape, markers, pipe cleaners and any other supplies that may be immediately available to make our idea tangible. Or, a prototype could be a sketch with role-playing to demonstrate a proposed communication process. In other words, the prototypes can be low fidelity so they don't use up much time and money. It's really about getting the concept across in the simplest, most cost-effective way to keep the process moving forward.
Step 5: Test. You then take each prototype to the end users you got input from in step 1 and let them react to it. Does it address their unmet needs and solve the problem they’re facing? Based on their feedback, you may need to revise the prototype and test it again.
At any point, repeat steps as needed. Just continue working the process until you come up with a solution that works — and that people will embrace.
Design thinking is rather new to health care, but we're seeing great value in it. It's really getting people to think in new ways and come up with innovative solutions. Plus, by creating low-fidelity prototypes, you can try things out with very low risk but potentially high impact.
So rather than waiting for a big grant to come through, try moving forward on human-centered design to see if you can create innovative solutions right away.
This post first appeared in the Microsoft in Health blog.
This post was updated after readers pointed out an inadvertent omission — the role of patients and family members in this work.
Dear Rhonda,
Thank you for your great article. I agree with everything you said. I wounder it would be important also to stress that the planned intervention should be as simple as possible. I imagine that in your work this is already happening, but I do wounder this should be one key objective of every new intervention to be implemented: to be as simple as possible. For example, by eliminating unnecessarily forms; simplifying forms language etc. Dr. Pronovost (from your hospital) talks about that in "Safe Patients, Smart Hospitals: How One Doctor's Checklist Can Help Us Change Health Care from the Inside Out", when he describes the steps involved in implementing protocol to reduce central catheter infection in ICUs. Besides the great team work needed to improve the safety culture (that he lead amazingly, as known by all involved in patient safety), we learned about his effort to make all the necessary equipment accessible to the ICU team. I know this is not news for you. Just want to highlight that.
Thanks again.
Alex
Alex -- Thanks for your comments. You are absolutely correct. We encourage teams who are problem-solving to consider the criteria below when developing their solutions: Is the solution:
1) simple?
2) easy to test?
3) evidence-based?
4) compatible with existing workflows whenever possible?
In some cases we try to disrupt the current process or system when needed, as in our current project highlighted in the blog.
Pingback: Re-blogging: “Five Steps to Innovative Solutions for Health Care Improvement” | Dr. Tavares' Blog on Patient Safety and Mental Health
I applaud your efforts and use of IDEO. However, even here I see you doing what you are comfortable with and what you know best. For me, there are two things that I would address. First, is interviewing patients and what they feel they need. The benefit of this is not only the patient perspective but the expertise the patients may have which they can bring into the process which is outside the insular ways of the healthcare system. Engineers, managers, teachers and many others that you wouldn't even suspect have insights that would open up the thinking. This could be a good use of your Patient Family Advisory Board members who are mostly relegated to helpful improve the scores on the HCAHPS rather than more meaningful work of helping the hospital learn how to communicate with each other and save lives. The second point is seeing a long term perspective in the context of not only acute care but in the long-term wellness of the patients. How does the team get feedback beyond the acute care boundary. Thank you...
Cathy -- Thanks for your comments on the blog. You are spot on. It was my oversight in the blog to not highlight our “North Star” as we are learning about the problem. Patients and families are almost always involved in the process (since they are users of our entire system) as we are gaining insights and deep empathy for the problem. The patient and their family as you and others will agree are at the very sharp end of all that we do, and designing solutions WITH them rather than FOR them is an imperative. Thank you for pointing out this oversight.
I absolutely agree with the above comment. When reading Step 1 in your blog, I had to reread it because I thought I overlooked the word patient. Designing a team and receiving feedback without the most important member of that team would be a monumental error. Interviewing patients and their families is essential. Perhaps not in the same setting with other health care professionals where the language and concerns may be a bit confusing for the average person, but certainly in another venue. Why not find out what is important to patients and their families? Their answers may surprise you.
Linda -- Agree completely, can’t believe I left out the most important person in the work.. the patient. That was a complete oversight. I want to ensure you that we almost always start with patient and their families, and include them throughout the process including in our prototyping. They add such an incredibly important layer of insight that we would not discover without them. So glad to hear that you value their insights as well.
Rhonda- incredible post! It's clear that healthcare is in desperate need of "divergent" thinking (courtesy of the IDEO philosophy on human centered design), and so glad to hear about your work at the Armstrong Institute. Here at Brown Medical School, we've started up an initiative called Design Plus Health where we work on healthcare problems with a design institute, starting from the beginning of the educational process of medical students and designers (designplushealth.org).
Much work that needs to be done. Agree with the comments above that the first step, Empathy, nearly always involves the Patient as that human in "human centered design"!
Pranav,
Thanks for your message. Love what you are doing at Brown http://www.designplushealth.org/#intro-2 thanks for sharing. I agree, reaching out to work with design students who have objective and unbiased views (except for their personal experiences) is an innovative approach to tackle many of the wicked problems in healthcare. We have been fortunate to collaborate here at Hopkins in Baltimore with MICA (Maryland Institute College of Art), and their MASD students take part in design challenges around healthcare where their identified solutions are often at the true center of viable, feasible, and desirable.
Would love to see how we could find synergy in some of the work that we are both doing.
Best,
Rhonda
Your article helped me a lot, is there any more related content? Thanks!
Thank you for your sharing. I am worried that I lack creative ideas. It is your article that makes me full of hope. Thank you. But, I have a question, can you help me?
Reason two - Russian cuisine is a rainbow of tastes (just be certain to give it a attempt no matter how terrified you're by the look of the dishes - a few of them look disgusting). Slavic magnificence has turn into a magnet for many foreigners, so there’s nothing shocking why 1000's of them look for women on-line. You may as well discover Russian ladies in well-liked inexpensive resorts in Cyprus, Egypt, and Turkey the place in addition they look for a chance to fulfill a international bridegroom. Intellectual charm. American men in search of intellectual stimulation want a partner who can have interaction in deep conversations about literature, philosophy, or history. Also, these males respect the artistry and a spotlight to detail that Slavic girls convey to their appearance, seeing it as a mirrored image of their partner’s sophistication and refined style. Men who aren’t trying for straightforward solutions can also listen to subtle Slovakian ladies for marriage. Russian girls are arduous-working and usually effectively-educated, particularly in big cities.
Is a Russian Bride Best for you? Looking for a nice and effectively-behaved Slavic mail order bride? An average Slavic mail order bride from this country is understood for being not solely engaging and fashionable but also open to new experiences and information. While particular laws and regulations related to mail order brides might vary between Slavic nations, usually, utilizing courting websites to connect with potential wives is taken into account reliable. Slavic women could typically take on roles associated with nurturing and caring for the house, while their partners are expected to offer for the family. EM Platinum membership. No one likes the shock chances are you'll get on Slavic online courting websites charging per letter or per minute. Additionally, MeetSlavicGirls has a wide range of messaging instruments similar to messaging, emailing, and video chat that enable users to get to know their potential matches higher before meeting in particular person. Will probably be considerably of an impediment when you find yourself assembly Slavic brides, as some of them only know English at a basic stage.
English guys would always play games and never text again and i needed to ‘follow the rules’ and never text back right away. American guys suggest equal relationships. A whole lot of European and American males date stunning Russian ladies and sometimes have difficulties pleasing them. There may be (and needs to be) loads of features that enable a member to contact and get closer to a Slavic woman online. Some men might discover this appealing, as it might probably provide stability and clear expectations inside the relationship. Regular communication, belief, and planning visits to each other's nations may help maintain a wholesome lengthy-distance relationship. Our members, men and women, reside in more than 200 international locations of the world. Are mail order brides authorized in Slavic countries? They’re compassionate, supportive, and kind, so these qualities prove that a Serbian mail order spouse is an ideal candidate for a partner. Some people accuse Belarus mail order brides of chasing cash and wealth in worldwide dating, however you possibly can go to a site and get right into a scam with other Slavic ladies as properly. They solely appear unapproachable, however in the event you study them higher, you’ll see that Romanian mail order wives are fairly talkative, pleasant, and open.
Romanian brides would set near and pricey in the first place and stay loyal wives to husbands despite any challenges confronted. It’s value mentioning the hot and quick temperament of Romanian ladies of marriage, so their potential companions must be affected person sufficient to get used to that! Where can I discover Slavic girls for marriage? Slavic girls for marriage from Serbia are another cause to visit a site with mail order brides. Strong household charmdate scam values. Slavic mail order brides are identified for his or her commitment to making a loving and harmonious family setting. What ought to men do to content material Slavic brides from Slovakia? Why Slavic ladies for marriage are perfect wives? Beautiful Slavic ladies are often considered to be good wives for several reasons. If taking a trip to the Slavic region will not be possible in the intervening time, then utilizing the web is a more realistic possibility. Since 1999, we've got had more than 2 million profiles on the positioning, and thousands of completely happy couples. These couples have by no means given up on their dreams, and found the love they dreamed about! These couples usually share a deep connection based on mutual respect, understanding, and a love for one another's tradition.